Skip to main content
Inherited Home Center

Sell, rent or keep calculator

Compare selling the house now with keeping it or renting it out for one to five years and then selling. You enter your own numbers and assumptions, and the calculator adds up the cash in and out for each choice. Taxes aren’t included, so treat the result as a starting point.

The house
Your own assumption. Values can go down as well as up.
Commission plus seller closing costs.
Mortgage
Costs of owning
Vacant and rental homes often need different coverage. Ask your agent.
If you rent it out
Share of rent collected. Use 0 if you manage it yourself.
Optional
If you sell now, what the money might earn. Leave at 0 to skip.

How the choices compare

Sell now

Cash from selling now
$274,000
Total after 3 years
$274,000

Keep 3 years, then sell

Holding costs and mortgage payments
−$26,400
Cash from the later sale
$274,000
Total after 3 years
$247,600

Rent 3 years, then sell

Rent minus costs and mortgage payments
$28,654
Cash from the later sale
$274,000
Total after 3 years
$302,654
Estimated home value in 3 years
$300,000

Not included: income tax on rent, depreciation, capital gains tax, or big surprises like a new roof. Taxes can be different for each choice, so ask a tax professional. Money matters, but so do your time, your family and your plans.

Estimates only. This is not legal, tax or financial advice.

How does this calculator work?

  • Sell now = value today − selling costs − cost to get ready − mortgage payoff. If you add a return, that money grows each year.
  • Keep, then sell = cash from selling later − taxes, insurance, HOA, maintenance, utilities and mortgage payments along the way.
  • Rent, then sell = cash from selling later + rent after vacancy and management − owning costs, mortgage payments and setup costs.
  • The later sale uses your yearly change in value and the mortgage balance after the payments you entered.

What isn’t included?

  • Income tax on rent, depreciation and capital gains. These can differ a lot between the choices. Ask a tax professional.
  • Big one-time surprises, like a new roof or a long vacancy
  • Your time, and what being a landlord involves

Want to talk it through?

Tell us about the home and we’ll help you think through your options. If you want help selling, we can match you with a vetted local agent who has handled inherited homes before. It costs you nothing.